Good: Cool Star-Warsy aesthetics, cool space battles, and badass light saber fights. A few really cool Mark Hamil moments.
Bad: Too many generic and tone-deaf jokey dialogue/moments. Way too much heavy-handed and clunky dramatic exposition. Too many weird bait-and-switch moments. Still too many overly obvious callbacks. Also, about an hour too long. Far from a subtle movie.
Best: I DID love the unexpected teaser trailer for Peter Jackson’s “Mortal Engines” that preceded the film though. That looked insane!